Based on a true story, charming Chicago-area officer Drew Peterson (Lowe) seemed virtually “untouchable” when it came to his womanizing ways, landing the eye of Stacy (Cuoco), a woman half his age, despite his marriage to third wife Kathleen (Cara Bruno, Mad Men). Even with a bitter divorce in front of him and the subsequent accidental drowning death of Kathleen in an empty bathtub, Drew carried on with his life without incident. But when Stacy mysteriously disappears, questions surface about Drew’s involvement. As Stacy’s disappearance draws national media attention, Drew seemingly basks in all the notoriety, all the while professing his innocence in any wrongdoing. Drew goes as far as getting engaged to another woman but when authorities take a look closer at Kathleen’s death, the spotlight is shone on Drew’s true colors. Are Kathleen’s death and Stacy’s still unknown whereabouts a tragic coincidence? Or is there more to what meets the eye?